Justine: Copy Editing Challenges You Can Easily Overcome: Apostrophes

wtd574.jpg

Cartoon by What the Duck.

Author by day, copy editor by night. That’s me. To keep myself occupied in the evenings (I’m not much for watching television) and to help pay for my book cover habit, I take copy editing jobs from select writers. In my former life, I had a ten-year career as a technical writer. Combine all of this experience and one starts to notice particular consistent misuses of various grammar guidelines (I don’t like the word “rules,” because there are some rules made to be broken).

Over the next several posts, I’m going to lay out a few basic guidelines, abuses, and misunderstandings of grammar in the hopes that you, fair writer, will learn them and will put them to good use. If you’re paying for copy editing, this will not only make your copy editor love you more (trust me, it will), but it will reduce the time it takes your copy editor to work through your manuscript.

Disclaimer: I use the Chicago Manual of Style as my “bible” for anything grammar- or copy editing-related. There are other style manuals which may offer differing views.

Today’s topic? Apostrophes

This is by far the most misunderstood and grossly abused grammar guideline. There are essentially two types of apostrophes:

  • Those that indicate possession (i.e., something belonging to someone/something else)
  • Those that indicate contractions (combining two words into one)

Let’s start with the easier one…apostrophes for contractions.

Contractions

Apostrophes for contractions are used when you are combining two words into one, often a noun or pronoun and a verb, but also with “not.” Examples:

  • It is = it’s
  • You are = you’re
  • They are = they’re
  • We had = we’d
  • He is = he’s
  • She will = she’ll
  • Let us = let’s
  • Do not = don’t
  • Can not = can’t

Its and it’s confuses a lot of people, but the general rule (okay, this is definitely a rule) with this sort of apostrophe is whether or not you can make two words out of it. If you can, it needs an apostrophe. It’s going to be a long night vs. We’re not sure what its purpose is.

Be Wary of Contractions Using “Is”

In conversation, we tend to blend our words together, particularly with the word “is” (and its past-tense cousin, “has”). When used with “it,” you have a recognizable contraction, “it’s.” But when you start combining “is” with other nouns, often proper nouns (anything with a capital letter), you can start to distort the meaning, because while we’ve trained our ears to hear the verb “is,” we haven’t necessarily trained our eyes to read it (and because of the issue of possession, which I’ll get to below). See these examples:

  • Janet is going to the baseball game vs. Janet’s going to the baseball game.
  • The dog is hiding in his doghouse vs. The dog’s hiding in his doghouse.
  • Julie has gone to the restroom vs. Julie’s gone to the restroom.

I think you’re pretty safe in quoted dialogue to use –’s with a noun/proper noun to create a contraction for “is,” but in my opinion (and the opinion of others, although I couldn’t find anything definitive in the Chicago Manual of Style), you should reserve it for dialogue only.

Possession

The most commonly misunderstood use of the apostrophe is the difference between plurality (more than one) and possession (belonging).

Apostrophes should be used to indicate possession. If what you’re writing about doesn’t belong to something or someone, don’t use an apostrophe.

Here are some examples of possession:

  • David’s phone is broken (the phone belongs to David)
  • Justine’s aggravation is evident (it’s her aggravation)
  • The writer’s new book is out (the book belongs to the writer)
  • The magician’s rabbit had fourteen bunnies (the rabbit belongs to the magician)

Where the abuse happens is when one is indicating plurality, or more than one. For example:

  • Forty-two bees, not forty-two bee’s
  • The energetic racers, not the energetic racer’s
  • Pots of honey, not pot’s of honey

At this point, you’re probably thinking, “Okay, I’ve got this. Only an idiot makes this mistake.” Well, there must be a lot of idiots out there. Consider these:

In all of these examples, there should be NO apostrophe (I hope you saw the tattoo mistake…that’s on there for life, buddy!).

Plural Possession and Words Ending in -S: Do You Use S’ or S’S

You will certainly have cases of both possession and plurality, or words ending in -s, as in the following examples:

  • The bass’s tank needs to be cleaned (the tank the bass is in)
  • The bees’ honey tastes sweet (the honey from the many bees)
  • The teachers’ schedules are crazy (multiple teachers and multiple schedules)
  • Artemis’s bow is broken (the bow belonging to Artemis)
  • The Lincolns’ marriage ended in divorce (the marriage of two people, the Lincolns)

There are four general guidelines here:

  • If the word is a singular noun that ends in -s  (like bass), add –’s
  • If the word is a plural noun that ends in -s (like bees or teachers), just add the apostrophe
  • If the word is a proper singular noun that ends in -s (like James or Artemis), add –’s
  • If the word is a proper plural noun that ends in -s (as in the Williamses’ home or the Lincolns’ marriage), just add the apostrophe

There are exceptions to these guidelines, of course. There are also other specialized circumstances that require apostrophes, but I’m trying to cover the 95% of abuses in this post. (To give you a hint, there are 27 different circumstances for using an apostrophe to indicate possession as outlined in the Chicago Manual of Style. You’ll probably use three of these most of the time.)

And now it’s time for “Ask the Copy Editor.” If you have specific questions about apostrophes, please ask in the comments below. I’d love to hear them!

5 thoughts on “Justine: Copy Editing Challenges You Can Easily Overcome: Apostrophes

  1. The one that gets missed often and that bugs me the most is when a word ends in S and it needs to be a possessive, but instead of ‘s, only the apostrophe is added. You see that in publications all the time. Although of course, there are essentially no professional copyeditors anymore, so it’s no wonder. Not to sound like a crank!

  2. Pingback: Justine: Avoiding Procrastination – Eight Ladies Writing

  3. Pingback: Justine: Copy Editing Challenges You Can Easily Overcome: Apostrophes — Eight Ladies Writing – Indian Manuscripts

Let Us Know What You Think

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s